In a surprising twist that’s left pizza lovers scratching their heads, Domino’s Pizza has recently introduced a parmesan-stuffed crust — and for many, this announcement felt anything but new. Across social media platforms, users are flooding comment sections with the same disbelief: “Wait… hasn’t Domino’s always had stuffed crust?” This is the latest Mandela Effect to go viral — and it’s especially jarring because it involves something as familiar and everyday as ordering a pizza.
Watch the Breakdown
Content creator All Time has covered this Mandela Effect in depth, digging into why so many remember a version of Domino’s that, officially, never existed prior to March 2025.
The Memory
Many people strongly remember Domino’s offering stuffed crust pizza long before 2025. For them, it was a common menu item, often ordered and even advertised alongside other Domino’s staples like the Brooklyn Style or Pan pizzas.
Some say they remember stuffed crust being a direct competitor to Pizza Hut’s version. In fact, there are even specific recollections of TV commercials or Domino’s coupons promoting their own take on the cheesy crust innovation. For these individuals, the memory is clear: Domino’s always had it — this isn’t something new.
The Reality
Despite these widespread memories, the official record says otherwise. Domino’s introduced its parmesan-stuffed crust pizza for the very first time in March 2025. The launch was widely covered in food blogs and media as a brand-new offering. Prior to this launch, Domino’s had never featured any type of stuffed crust on their menu.
That hasn’t stopped the outcry. From TikTok to Reddit to YouTube, users are expressing disbelief, convinced that Domino’s stuffed crust is a long-lost favorite brought back — not a debut. It’s a classic case of the Mandela Effect: a false memory shared by many, now brought into question by current reality.
Have you ever had stuffed crust from Domino’s before March 2025 — or do you just think you did? Drop a comment and let us know what you remember.
—
The MandelaEffects.net Team
