Disney-Pixar’s Toy Story franchise has been a beloved part of many childhoods, filled with memorable characters, heartfelt moments, and iconic quotes. But like other cultural staples, Toy Story hasn’t escaped the phenomenon of Mandela Effects—those eerie discrepancies between collective memories and current reality. Here are five Mandela Effects from the Toy Story films that have fans scratching their heads.
1. The Song in Buzz Lightyear’s Sad Flying Scene
Many fans vividly remember the heart-wrenching moment in Toy Story when Buzz Lightyear tries to fly, only to crash and realize he’s just a toy. The scene was emotional, and for years, people recall the melancholic tune of “What a Wonderful World” by Louis Armstrong playing in the background.
However, upon revisiting the film, the song that plays is “I Will Go Sailing No More” by Randy Newman—a beautiful but completely different tune. For some, this is a minor change, but for others, it feels like an emotional memory has shifted entirely.
Revisit this scene above and see for yourself!
2. Sid’s Dog: Spike or Scud?
Sid, the toy-destroying kid next door, has a ferocious pet dog in Toy Story. Many remember the dog’s name being Spike, which matches his rough, intimidating nature.
Shockingly, his name is actually Scud. While both names fit Sid’s wild personality, the switch from “Spike” to “Scud” has left fans questioning their recollections.
3. Sporky or Forky in Toy Story 4?
Toy Story 4 introduced a quirky new character—a white plastic spork with googly eyes and pipe-cleaner arms. Many fans remember this character being named Sporky, reflecting the fact that he’s made from a spork.
But no—his name is actually Forky! Despite being crafted from a spork, the character is officially called Forky in all the movie’s materials. For fans, this inexplicable name choice feels like a Mandela Effect in action.
4. Woody’s Iconic Snake Quote
Woody, everyone’s favorite cowboy doll, is known for his classic pull-string quotes. One of his most iconic lines is: “There’s a snake in my boot.”
Or is it? Revisiting the films, Woody actually says: “There’s a snake in my boots.” For fans, this plural version feels off, especially if they grew up quoting the singular “boot.” Could this be another instance of collective memory being rewritten?
Revisit this scene above and see for yourself!
Curious to dive deeper? Check out this fascinating YouTube video by a Mandela Effect researcher, where he breaks down this specific change. Watch it HERE.
5. The Claw Scene: “One of Us”
One of the most iconic scenes in Toy Story is the Claw Machine Scene, where Buzz Lightyear leaps into a toy machine filled with the little green aliens who chant “The Claw.” For many fans, this moment is unforgettable—not just for their worship of the claw but also because of another chant.
Many distinctly remember the aliens also saying, “One of us,” a phrase that added an eerie and humorous layer to their hive-like behavior. However, upon revisiting the scene, the aliens never utter “One of us” at all.
This iconic moment takes place at Pizza Planet, where Buzz mistakenly believes the claw machine is a spaceship. The aliens worship “The Claw” as a divine force, leading to a hilarious and memorable interaction. But the absence of “One of us” has left some fans questioning if their memory has been altered—or if the Mandela Effect has struck again.
What’s even stranger? If you search “Toy Story one of us” on YouTube or Google, many of the top results point directly to the claw scene. It’s as though the association persists despite no evidence of the line existing in the film itself. Could this be further residue of an alternate memory?
Revisit the Claw Machine scene above and see for yourself!
What Do You Remember?
These Mandela Effects leave fans wondering: are our childhood memories being reshaped, or is something deeper at play? Revisit these scenes and characters to see what you remember:
- Watch Buzz’s flying scene and listen for the song—does it feel different?
- Pay attention to Sid’s dog and whether “Scud” feels right.
- Revisit Toy Story 4 and see if you recall the name Sporky instead of Forky.
- Pull the string on Woody’s back and decide: is it boot or boots?
- Jump into the Claw Machine scene at Pizza Planet—do the aliens chant “One of us,” or is it just “The Claw”?
Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below! Which of these Mandela Effects feels the most real to you?
